Yes, the media center (MC) PC is dead.I had come across
an interesting article on the Inquirer. While it's only a commentary, it does raise a few interesting points.
"Sadly, on the marketing front three years after launching, its not so much that consumers are frightened by them but that they dont even know that they exist. Far from leaping over the IT/living fence, Media Center PCs have instead managed to land on their nuts on the top," posted Martin Lynch, author of the article.
Of our personal observations, we did not even hear about MC's in the last 3 years, until our team wanted to make one ourselves. Essentially, whatever marketing that Microsoft, Dell, HP, etc. has done, in our opinion, has been a failure. In the UK, only 4f all desktop PC sales were media center systems. It's heard to be about as dismal in the US. Even worse, these MC's are usually bought and used as desktops - but it's never used as a MC. I know two friends that bought media center PC's, never ever caring that it can be used as a MC.
At any rate, as "perfect" as some may deem these media centers, there are still many severe problems with them.
***
1. People do not want to be attached to a PC. Most people watch TV, DVDs, etc. on a TV screen, not a PC flat panel/monitor. Many MC's come with TV-outputs, but are sometimes limited to composite or S-video, which are not suitable for high definition viewing.
2. Most media center systems have inadequate storage. Some of the MC's being offered only come with as little as 80GB of storage standard. Adding in the operating system, main programs, and other support utilities, you may have as little as less than 30 hours for television shows recorded at high fidelity. That's less than the standard 40 hours offered by most DVR/PVR/Tivo® systems. Add in music, pictures, videos, and other media, you can quickly see how conventional media center systems are very lacking. In additional, related to storage is point...
3. Lack of protected storage. Like most PC's, people have encountered crashes, hard drives (HD's) malfunctioning, etc. Can the public really trust their irreplaceable pictures, videos, and other memories to the risk of a HD crash? Can they replace their entire music collection? Backup systems are available which protect the data, but the system will still fail and stop working if a HD malfunctions.
4. Typical MC's are noisy. Because they come with stock equipment - standard fans & casing - noise is often a problem. How would a user like to hear a humming noise while s/he is watching his/her favorite movie? A small amount of noise maybe acceptable in a work environment, but not in a home theater environment.
5. Unsightly, large, and/or ugly looking cases. This is one of the biggest common complaints. Standard MC PC's - even the "small form factor" ones - are still too odd-shaped and/or large to be fitted into a standard entertainment center or TV stand.
6. Lastly, many companies have concentrated too much on price, and not functionality. Conventional MC PC's are marketed as that - PC's. The major manufacturers, so far, have tried to keep a low price on it (understandably), but at the price of limiting/removing many of the features mentioned above.
***
Even with these problems above, the premise of a media center
system (not necessarily a PC) is not dead. How? By improving the basic design, which is what out
VidaBox media center line of products has achieved.
1. The SLIM, LUX, and MAX media centers offer VGA, DVI/HDMI*, component, s-video, and composite outputs - 5 of the most popular video transmission formats available today. Connect the VidaBox to any TV you have - it's guaranteed to connect.
2. VidaBox systems come with 250GB to 750GB of storage - standard. They are also upgradeable up to 2.2TB (that's terabytes - 2,200GB) on the Max and Lux systems, enough for hundreds of hours of recorded TV, 100,000's songs, 500,000 pictures, and more. The ideal system should not limit your saved data and force you to delete precious items.
3. VidaSafe - our protected storage system - comes standard on the SLIM, LUX, and MAX. If a HD stops working - don't worry! You'll get a simple notification stating that an HD has stopped working - but your data is still safe, and the VidaBox will still operate.
4. Our advanced case designs are engineered to minimize noise. The ROOMMATE is as quiet as 27dBA - other models are 30dBA or quieter - which is softer than a whisper. Don't worry about noise disturbing your viewing or listening experience ever again.
5. Not only are VidaBox cases quiet, but they are also asthetically pleasing. With sleek and stylish designs, the ROOMMATE and SLIM, at about 4" tall, can fit easily into any home theater setup. The LUX and MAX, with their full size, can easily be rack mounted into any standard 19" A/V rack stand.
See some pictures for yourself here!
6. Realizing that creating a cheap product that doesn't sell is pointless, VidaBox systems are designed to be
Premium home theater systems. Complete in every respect, VidaBox units aren't just another everyday purchase - but an investment in your home entertinament experience.
* - DVI/HDMI output on the SLIM requires a video card upgrade.
Sincerely,
The VidaBox Media Center & Home Theater PC / HTPC Team